
Boston Light, on tiny Little Brewster Island at the outer edge of Boston Harbor, is the oldest light station in the United States. Its first keeper drowned within sight of it two years after it opened, and one keeper’s wife later wrote that she heard a girl crying a drowned man’s name across the water. Here is the history, the legend and the honest answer to whether you can go there.
History
According to the National Park Service, Massachusetts built the first tower in 1716: a slightly tapered rubblestone tower about 60 feet high, lit by candles, with a keeper’s house, barn and wharf. Fires and storms damaged it repeatedly. During the Revolutionary War, patriot troops burned it more than once in July 1775 while the British held it, and in June 1776 the departing British blew it up. Massachusetts did not rebuild until 1783. That 75-foot rubblestone tower is the one that stands today, raised to 89 feet in 1859 to take a second-order Fresnel lens.
Boston Light was electrified in 1948. In 1964 it became a National Historic Landmark. In 1989 Congress required that it remain permanently staffed, which made it the last staffed lighthouse in the country; it was automated in 1998 but kept its keepers. Dr. Sally Snowman became the first civilian keeper since 1941, and the first woman to hold the post, in 2003. She retired in 2023, and the Park Service calls her the last official lighthouse keeper in the United States.
The ghost stories
The legend starts with a documented tragedy. In November 1718 the first keeper, George Worthylake, his wife and a daughter drowned when their boat capsized as they returned to the island. The Boston Harbor Islands partnership says an enslaved man named Shadwell paddled out to bring them ashore and died with them, while another daughter waited on the island. The New England Lighthouses site (nelights.com) gives the daughter who drowned as Ruth and the one who watched as Ann.
The best-known ghost account comes from Mazie Anderson, whose family helped tend the light in 1947. She told it in Yankee magazine in October 1998, and the Boston Harbor Islands blog retells it. In her telling:
- She heard footsteps behind her on the beach, and later maniacal laughter from the boathouse, which her husband said was a loon.
- One foggy November evening, with her husband ill and the other keepers ashore, the fog-signal engines started on their own, and as she went to light the beacon she saw it come on with a figure outlined against the lens.
- That night she heard a girl’s voice sobbing “Shadwell! Shadwell!” near the mooring. Only years later, she said, did she read about the 1718 drowning.
Later stories, collected on nelights.com, include a Coast Guardsman’s boathouse radio switching from rock to classical music, the foghorn sounding on clear nights, and a faint woman on the stairs of the keeper’s house. These are anecdotes, not records. The drowning is history; the voices are legend.
Visiting (checked October 2026)
You cannot land on the island right now. The National Park Service says Boston Light and Little Brewster Island are not open to the public because of safety and access issues, and the Boston Harbor Islands cruise page says there is no public access “due to ongoing maintenance following winter storms.” No date for reopening has been announced, so the tower cannot be climbed.
What you can do is see it from the water. The Boston Harbor Islands Lighthouse Cruise is a two-hour narrated trip past Long Island Head Light, Graves Light and Boston Light, departing from the Boston Harbor Islands Welcome Center on the Rose Kennedy Greenway in downtown Boston (across from the Marriott Long Wharf). The 2026 season ran on Saturdays in summer and has ended. 2026 prices were $41 adults, $36 seniors, students and military, $30 children 4 to 11, and free for 3 and under. Arrive 30 minutes early; trips can be cancelled for weather. Check the cruise page for the 2027 schedule.
Frequently asked questions
Is Boston Light haunted?
Legend says so. The best-known account comes from a keeper’s wife in 1947 who heard a girl calling “Shadwell,” the name of a man who drowned with the first keeper in 1718. The drowning is documented; the ghost is not.
Can you visit or climb Boston Light?
Not at present. The island is closed to the public; you can see the light from a summer Lighthouse Cruise.
Is Boston Light the oldest lighthouse in America?
It is the oldest light station, established in 1716. The current tower dates from 1783 because the British blew up the original in 1776.
Who was the last keeper?
Dr. Sally Snowman, keeper from 2003 until she retired in 2023.
More haunted lighthouses in New England: Seguin Island Lighthouse (ME) and New London Ledge Lighthouse (CT).
Sources
- National Park Service: Boston Light: history, keepers and the public access statement
- Boston Harbor Islands: “The Ghost of Boston Light” (2021): retelling of Mazie Anderson’s 1998 Yankee article
- New England Lighthouses: Haunted Lighthouses of Massachusetts: later ghost anecdotes and the Worthylake daughters’ names
- Boston Harbor Islands: Lighthouse Cruise: departure point, prices and access notice
Shop the gear
Heads up: NicheStuff is our own shop, so we earn from purchases made through these links. Prices and availability are set on the store and can change.
Top image: Boston Light, Little Brewster Island, Boston. Photo by Robert Linsdell via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)
